Your privacy choice

You can allow Facebook advertising and personalization so we can show ads to people who visited Resting Sycamore. Facebook and Google Tag Manager receive a generic Resting Sycamore site visit, not which page you viewed, what you searched for, or anything you type into a form. As with ordinary web requests, they also receive routine network information such as your IP address, browser or device details, timestamps, and identifiers or cookies they may already recognize.

Resting Sycamore Advisors938-238-5652
Medicare Advantage · Plan changes · Coverage decisions

Your Medicare Advantage plan is ending. Here is what to check next.

A notice that your plan is ending or leaving your county is not an emergency — but it does have a deadline. The right next step depends on which situation you are actually in.

Peter Abilla · Licensed Medicare Insurance Sales Agent
Alabama, California, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Texas, Utah, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Michigan, and Illinois

Where would you like to start?

Start with the line that matches your letter, or read it front to back.

Nothing here needs deciding today — but your enrollment window has a specific close date. Read the notice carefully. If you are not sure what it says, bring it to a phone call and I will read it with you.

Is my plan ending or only changing?

These are two different situations and they come with different letters.

Plan non-renewal (ending)

Your plan will no longer exist in your county after December 31. You will receive an Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) and a separate non-renewal notice. You must actively choose new coverage or you will be returned to Original Medicare automatically.

Plan changes (same plan, different terms)

Your plan continues, but premiums, drug lists, provider networks, or cost sharing are changing. You are not required to act — but you may want to compare options during the Annual Enrollment Period. Your ANOC will list what is changing.

Plan leaving your county

Some plans are approved in specific counties and withdraw from certain areas. If your county is dropped, you are in the same situation as a non-renewal — you need to pick new coverage.

When you are not sure

The letter will say "non-renewal notice" or will include a phrase like "your plan will not be renewed." If it only lists changes to benefits and costs, the plan is continuing. If you are reading the letter and still not sure, bring it to the phone call.

The distinction matters because non-renewal triggers a Special Enrollment Period with specific rights. Plan changes trigger Annual Enrollment Period shopping, which every Medicare beneficiary has.

When does my current coverage stop, and how long do I have to choose?

If your plan is ending or leaving your county, your current coverage stops on December 31 of the current plan year.

You can pick new coverage between December 8 and the last day of February of the following year. That window is your Special Enrollment Period — it is specific to your situation and it runs independently of the regular Annual Enrollment Period, which closes December 7.

  1. Before December 7 (Annual Enrollment Period). You can enroll in any Medicare Advantage plan or return to Original Medicare and a stand-alone Part D drug plan. This is the period when most options are available and advertising is loudest.
  2. December 8 through December 31. You can still use your Special Enrollment Period to pick new coverage that starts January 1.
  3. January 1 through the last day of February. Your Special Enrollment Period continues if you have not yet made a choice. New coverage starts the first of the following month. Do not wait until February — you want your new coverage confirmed before your first doctor visit of the year.

If you do nothing, you are not left without Medicare. CMS will move you to Original Medicare starting January 1. You will still have your red, white, and blue Medicare card. What you may not have is prescription drug coverage — Original Medicare does not include it. That is the gap that catches people who wait too long.

Deadlines are worth confirming against your specific letter and your specific plan. 938-238-5652 — bring the letter if you have it.

Can I choose another Medicare Advantage plan?

In most cases, yes. Your Special Enrollment Period lets you enroll in any Medicare Advantage plan available in your county, not just one offered by the same company.

Before choosing, check three things for each plan you are considering:

  • Your doctors. Is each doctor you see in the plan's network? Call the office and ask — do not rely on an online directory alone, because they are updated on different schedules than the actual network.
  • Your prescriptions. Is every drug you take on the plan's formulary at a tier that is manageable? Bring your full medication list. The tier a drug sits on can vary significantly between plans.
  • Your county. Plans are approved county by county. A plan a friend has in the next town may not be available where you live. Your ZIP code is the starting point for any real comparison.

If you stay in Medicare Advantage, also consider whether the new plan has year-to-year stability — whether it has been in your county for multiple years is a reasonable indicator, though not a guarantee.

Tell me your ZIP code and I will tell you what is actually approved where you live this plan year.

Can I return to Original Medicare?

Yes. A plan non-renewal or withdrawal from your county gives you the right to leave Medicare Advantage and return to Original Medicare. That is part of what the Special Enrollment Period covers.

Original Medicare means:

  • Part A (hospital) and Part B (medical) — administered directly by the federal government
  • No network — any doctor who accepts Medicare, anywhere in the country
  • No prior authorization for most services
  • No built-in drug coverage — you would need a stand-alone Part D plan
  • No cap on out-of-pocket costs — many people pair it with a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policy for that reason

Whether returning to Original Medicare makes sense depends on your health situation, your finances, and what Medigap options are available to you. It is not automatically better — it is a different set of trade-offs.

If you return to Original Medicare and want a Medigap policy, there is a timing rule that may give you guaranteed access to certain plans without medical underwriting. That is the next section.

Do I have guaranteed Medigap rights when my plan ends?

This is the part of the non-renewal situation that catches people off guard — and it may be the most valuable thing on this page.

Federal law gives you a guaranteed-issue right to certain Medigap plans when your Medicare Advantage plan ends through no fault of your own. Guaranteed issue means the insurance company cannot refuse you coverage or charge you more because of your health history.

The federal rule says you may have the right to Medigap Plan A, B, C, D, F, G, K, or L from any company that sells Medigap in your state if you switch to Original Medicare. If you were new to Medicare on or after January 1, 2020, Plans C and F are not available to you. Medicare says you have the right to Plans D and G instead.

The application window: You can apply starting 60 days before your Medicare Advantage coverage ends and no more than 63 days after it ends. Medicare.gov explains the federal window here.

The post-termination window is short, especially if you are also shopping for a new Medicare Advantage plan. These are two separate decisions. The Medigap deadline keeps moving whether or not you have made the other choice.

State law may expand this right. Several states require insurance companies to sell Medigap to anyone who applies, regardless of health, outside of the federal windows. Alabama, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Utah each have their own rules on top of the federal baseline. The state rules can be more generous — or they can create exceptions the federal rule does not. Worth confirming which rules apply to you before assuming.

  1. Confirm your plan is non-renewing, not just changing. The guaranteed-issue right applies to non-renewals and withdrawals, not to plans that continue with modified benefits.
  2. Mark the date your coverage ends. You can apply 60 days before that date and no more than 63 days after it.
  3. Compare Medigap options before the window closes. Medigap premiums are not regulated in most states, so the same plan can cost very different amounts from different companies. The benefits within each available letter (A, B, C, D, F, G, K, or L) are standardized.
  4. Apply before you also need to enroll in Part D. Medigap does not include drug coverage. If you are returning to Original Medicare, you need both.

Medigap rights are time-sensitive in a way that most Medicare decisions are not. This one has a clock.

Worth a phone call to confirm which window applies to you and which plans are available in your state. 938-238-5652 — weekdays, 9am–5pm Mountain.

What happens to my doctors and prescriptions during the transition?

When your Medicare Advantage plan ends, your network contracts end with it. Your doctors do not automatically move to a new plan — each plan has its own network and its own negotiations.

For doctors:

  • Do not assume continuity. Call each office and ask whether they accept the new plan you are considering.
  • If you are returning to Original Medicare, any doctor who accepts Medicare will see you — the network concern goes away, but cost sharing changes.
  • If you are in active treatment or recently had a procedure, ask about transition-of-care rules. Some plans offer a limited period to continue seeing out-of-network providers while your care transitions.

For prescriptions:

  • Each Medicare Advantage plan with drug coverage has its own formulary. A drug covered at Tier 2 on your old plan may be Tier 4 or not covered at all on a new plan.
  • If you are returning to Original Medicare, you need a stand-alone Part D plan. There is a Special Enrollment Period for this tied to the same non-renewal event.
  • Specialty drugs and brand-name drugs are the highest risk. Confirm those specifically for any plan you are considering.

Bring your full medication list and a list of your doctors to any comparison conversation. Checking both against the specific plan is the only way to get a real answer for your situation.

What if someone called me about this and I did not call them first?

Plan non-renewals create a burst of outbound calls from agents, lead-buyers, and call centers. Some of that contact is not allowed.

An agent or plan may not:

  • Call you about a Medicare Advantage plan if you did not first request information from them
  • Send you a text, social media message, or email you did not ask for
  • Come to your home uninvited
  • Pressure you to decide before you are ready
  • Ask for your Medicare number in order to "check your options"

What you can do: Hang up. You are allowed to. You can also ask for the caller's name, their agency, and their license number. A licensed agent in good standing will give you all three.

Your Medicare number is treated like your Social Security number for a reason. No agent needs it to explain what plans are available in your county — they need only your ZIP code and your permission to have a conversation.

If you want unbiased help that is not selling anything, every state has a SHIP — State Health Insurance Assistance Program. They do not sell plans. Call 1-800-MEDICARE and ask for your state's SHIP.

What should I ask any agent before making a decision?

Ask these of anyone you speak with. Including me.

  1. How many plans do you represent in my county?
  2. Are my current doctors in this plan's network?
  3. Are my medications on this plan's formulary at a reasonable tier?
  4. Has this plan been available in my county for more than one year?
  5. What is the maximum out-of-pocket limit for this plan?
  6. If I return to Original Medicare instead, what Medigap options are available to me and at what cost?
  7. What is the deadline for my specific situation?

If an agent cannot answer question one, that tells you something about how many options you are actually being shown.

Who wrote this?

Peter Abilla · Licensed Medicare Insurance Sales Agent
Resting Sycamore Advisors
Licensed in Alabama, California, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Texas, Utah, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Michigan, and Illinois

Insurance licenses: Alabama 3004331330 · California 4576435 · Ohio 1753385 · Pennsylvania 1323868 · Texas 3542255 · Utah 1123762 · New Jersey 3004401038 · New York 1993623 · North Carolina 22265186 · Michigan 22265186 · Illinois 22265186.

Last updated

Quoted on Medicare in Newsweek, NTD, and InsuranceNewsNet — as commentary, not endorsement.

Makaistorya ko og Binisaya.

My services are $0.00, forever. The carriers we represent compensate us, but my service to you will always be $0.00.

A first conversation is mostly questions. Your letter, your doctors, your prescriptions, your county. Often the answer is that one of the available options in your area fits you well, and I say so. Sometimes the answer is to go back to Original Medicare. I will tell you what I see either way.

Want to talk through your notice with someone?

Call or leave a message
938-238-5652

A real person, not a call center. If I am with someone, leave a message and I will call you back the same day.

Tell me your ZIP code and what your letter says. I will tell you which window applies to you and what is actually available where you live.